I've been interested in essential oils for a while now, beginning with a Facebook post where I sought out questions that might come up regarding essential oils and their use in children. Well, after much consideration, study and investigation, I think it’s time to release some of those results.

Whether you agree with my conclusions or not, I think you’ll find the information helpful and interesting…so here goes!

The slippery assumptions of oil supporters

We all have pre-conceived ideas about things. We can’t help ourselves. We were brought up in a particular culture or educated in a certain way or have friends that believe certain things. One of my primary goals as a person is to constantly challenge what to believe to see if there are holes in my thinking or understanding of things that are not logical.

I’m going to go ahead and put some of my pre-conceived notions and assumptions out there so that we can all be on the same page:

1.I have a strong trust in science, the scientific method and organized medicine. I can’t blindly follow any of those things, but I’m going to rely on them most of the time to make decisions for myself, my children and my patients. If the science proves that something works, I’m willing to use it or at least allow it to be used by my families.

2.I am very skeptical of anecdotal stories and advice. I often have to say, “I can’t contradict what you are saying, but it goes against what I know about this condition.”

3.I am generally very nervous about new treatments or new uses for old treatments. I often say, “I don’t want to be the first to try something nor the last. Somewhere in between is where I feel comfortable.” I want to weight risk vs benefit for everything.

4.I believe that the overwhelming percentage of parents (99.9999 percent) want the best for their child and would never intentionally harm their children in any way.

Because of these assumptions, I may evaluate oils in a different way than most people who use them do. I get that. But my patients who use them will tell you that when we talk about them, I am not judgmental (at least, I try not to be) and I am willing to listen to how they are using them as long as they will listen in return when I provide suggestions or push-back. (Most of them pretend to listen, at least, ha!)

I thought as we move through all the evidence about oils I have discovered, it would be helpful to challenge some statements made by my oily friends that imply false assumptions about me:

1.“I just don’t want to give them medicine for every little thing.”

That’s awesome, me neither. When patients leave my practice, it’s most commonly because I don’t give them a medicine or test that they want. The four most common examples are medicine for colds (cough and congestion), reflux, colic or antibiotics. If medications are not indicated for those conditions, I’m not going to be writing for them. If the decision is on the fence or unclear, I’ll engage the parents to help make a decision. The three little kids running around my house rarely get any medicine, especially for those symptoms for which I see oils being used. They rarely get medicine for fever or runny nose, never for cough and certainly never because their behavior is bad that day. Most of you probably don’t use oils for this-but some of you do…I’ve seen it. I’m not trying to single out a child with special needs or developmental problems, I’m more referencing a kid/parent who just aren’t quite getting along that day. In many of these cases, the use of oils is not in place of a medication, it is often additional to what I would do.

2.“You are a medical doctor so I’m sure you don’t like alternative medicine.”

Not exactly but this one is closer to true. Traditional medicine, to me, means tried, tested and proven. Alternative medicine might be old, might be tried but in my mind the definition means that it is unproven. In fact, through my studies the last few weeks, I have come across a couple of ideas that I am considering incorporating into my practice. But, at that point, if I begin to recommend it based on review of the scientific literature, is it alternative? Or, if the oils work like some claim they do, then eventually won’t we all be using them? Are they still alternative? This assumption is partially true but only because I want to be clear with my patients on what we absolutely know about oils, not what some have claimed.

3.Patients don’t tell me about their oils because they are scared of my reaction or assume I don’t want to know.

Incredibly wrong. I have to know what medication your child is on, period. If there is information about drug interactions or negative outcomes as a result of any medication use, I need to know who’s taking it so I can get in touch with people who are using them. We do the same thing for vaccines and everything else we use in the office so that if there is a recall or another issues, we can get the word out to our patients and tell them what to be on the lookout for.

Now we can move on to some research…

The Research on Essential Oils in Kids

These are the oils for which I found some research. I’m sure I left some off but I thought these were a representative list from a Facebook question I saw come across my timeline and would give us enough information to start the discussion.

Lavender

Tea tree

Chamomile

Peppermint

Eucalyptus

Where did I look?

I started by looking myself and then had our staff librarian follow up with a PubMed search. Because I knew that would not be enough for some, I also reviewed the following websites at the suggestion of the followers of my Facebook page (The Doc Smitty): aromaticscience.com, Dr. Robert Pappas Essential Oil University and airase.com (cost me $75). I also used the NIH Center for Complimentery and Integrative Health, the MedLine Encyclopedia & Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database and the Sloan Kettering Integrative Medicine Database.

First, I’ll summarize what we found from the more traditional medical research on each oil (PubMed, NIH Complimentary and Integrative Health, MedLine and Sloan Kettering):

Lavender

• One study shows use of lavender associated with decreased use of acetaminophen after children had their tonsils out but did not show decrease in pain intensity or nighttime awakenings. (48 patients)
• Several adult studies showing calming effect of lavender.
• Another very small study showed that lavender use in babies had a calming effect.
• These and other published research involve small sample sizes (less then 50 subjects) and often the study design is lacking or flawed in other ways.

Tea tree oil

• Some fair quality studies that included children showed some possible benefit for lice, acne and warts.
• A small study in adults showed possible improvement in toenail fungus.
• Many reports of side effects from accidental overdose are pretty common with tea tree oil (confusion, drowsiness and possibly coma). Just a reminder (just like other medicines, I’m not singling out oils) that we should keep these oils out of the reach of children. I have seen people make comments like, “These are natural so you can’t possible overdose on them.” This is simply not true.

Chamomile

• A review of the use of alternative methods for treating colic (including chamomile) was published in Pediatrics in 2011. The conclusion of the reviewers was that a further look into the issue was warranted.
• Colic studies are difficult because defining what is colic is difficult, if we can agree, deciding what constitutes improvement is even harder as most “cases” resolve on their own without treatment.

Peppermint Oil

• Some studies (some including children) have shown benefit for use in irritable bowel syndrome and recurrent abdominal pain.
• Other possible uses have been studied in adults (including headache), which has shown some promise but no definitive answers have been found at this point.

Eucalyptus

• Studies have shown that use of eucalyptus and lemon can work as an insect repellant although there have been case reports of toxicity from widespread application on the skin.
• There are multiple reports of severe toxicity after excess ingestion in children.
• Some studies have shown benefit for treating head lice.

We tried to research some other oils (thieves and frankincense) but found any evidence for their use in children to be lacking or unavailable.

Of note, you’ll see that there is no evidence for the use of these oils for some of the common uses I see them touted as being beneficial for: fever, cough, congestion, allergies, teething symptoms and (the one that makes me the most frustrated-see above) behavior problems.

Other Sources

At the suggestion of readers I also reviewed the literature from aromaticscience.com and discovered one article for which I had not previously found and only discovered 11 studies when searching for children.

I also reviewed Dr. Robert Pappas’ website but could not find further information about studies in children.

The gist of most of these websites is to list tons of articles of test tube and animal models with adult studies mixed in but they have very little to no information on children.

An example of this is the Facebook page of Scott Johnson who is “one of the world’s leading experts on evidence-based, therapeutic use of essential oils and natural products.” I looked back over 6 months of his postings on Facebook. There are roughly 2-3 posts per day. I found four posts related to children: one about probiotic use for colic, one about mother/baby skin-to-skin contact, one promoting increased physical activity in kids, and one about exercise during pregnancy promoting brain growth in children. None that truly show evidence of the efficacy or safety of the use of essential oils in kids.

Finally, I signed up for a website so that I could review a study that got a lot of buzz last year in the essential oil community. It was looking at the use of oils in autism spectrum disorder (ASD). You can read more about ASD in my post here. There are many issues with the study that limit its ability to be used as proof of effectiveness: the sample size is small (12) and there is no control group (even a group that used a different concoction of oils would be helpful). It’s not that this type of study should not prompt further thinking into the issue, it’s just that the number of children and parents who started using oils for autism based on it is inappropriate. For more traditional investigations into the use of medications for autism, this would be one of the most preliminary studies and would need to be followed up by significant further studies to test for effectiveness and safety of the regimen that was recommended. Why do I care so much? Because my parents of children with developmental concerns are desperate for something that might help. I’m desperate to have something more to offer them, but I am very protective of them when it comes to those who might take advantage of them.

Summary of Research

There’s just not much out there. What is out there is small studies or case reports and other poor study designs. This effectively turns their current use by consumers into the study of essential oils. The problems is that, with no oversight, no one is systematically watching for effectiveness or safety so we may not know until much later.

Effectiveness/General Use

Do they really work or is it a mind over matter thing?

I think that there are probably some uses for oils that will be studied and proven to work. I think these will be pretty rare and only a small fraction of the claims that are currently made.

So, is it mind of matter (placebo)? Here are some of the most common uses I see for oils in kids:

Teething - It’s not even clear what symptoms teething causes …fussiness, fever, runny nose, etc have all come into question. But, if you give an oil and a symptom goes away, does that mean the oil fixed it? Not likely.

Fever - Fevers come and go during the day with illness, even without medication.

Cough/congestion - The regimens I see where children have oils placed frequently basically make it impossible to know if they do anything for these symptoms. Cough/congestion will be worse at certain times of day and better at others treatment or no.

How close are we to having actual research on the use of oils?

I still think we are quite some time away. Those that are currently doing research are often biased, are not doing high-quality studies and are using small sample sizes.

Marketing

Why are they sold through multi-level marketing (MLM)?

It’s a fast way to get a product out there and make a lot of money. Since I’ve been on social media, I’ve seen several of these types of MLM ideas crop up. The difference with these is I have some specific knowledge about the conditions they are being used for and specific concerns about how their use could harm a population of people that I care very much about. I know very little about bags and good smelling wax that can be melted with a light-bulb so I haven’t gotten involved until now.

In many ways, it protects the big company because they are not the ones out there making claims about the oils and what they can do. That falls to their independent distributors. If someone were to have a bad outcome because of their use of essential oils, who is responsible? If I prescribe a medicine that someone is allergic to, that responsibility falls squarely on my shoulders, not the makers of amoxicillin. If I prescribe the wrong medicine for a kids asthma and something bad happens, that responsibility falls to me.

Are they an increasingly popular trend or just something I was not aware of?

I’m not sure but it certainly does feel like they are gaining in popularity. Social media makes it seem that way at least.

Do you believe the claim that certain brands of oils are superior to others?

I’m sure there are differences but since we don’t even know what they do for the most part, it’s hard to answer this question.

Philosophy/Opinion

Regarding writing about essential oils: Are you mad, man?

Yes, in fact, I think I must be.

What’s the number one reason you see parents using oils instead of medicine?

In general, people are becoming less trusting of experts and organized institutions. Medicine and doctors are no different. The gap between what a doctor knows and what patients know shrinks every day. People can find out information about their conditions and know basically the treatment options that exist. People are looking to live more natural lives and most who use them feel that oils fit within that idea. When you combine these two issues, right or wrong, essential oils seem to step in the gap.

What is a good way to communicate with your doctor about your use of essential oils (for specific conditions and generally)?

I think it’s important to be honest with you doctor about your use of essential oils. As new information is uncovered it would be important for your doctor to be able to show you new research etc, especially if something shows a particular oil to be unsafe. They can only do this if they know about your use of them. Also, as doctors are prescribing medications, we need to know anything you might be on that could cause a drug interaction.

What is your take on the potential political barriers to the study of essential oils given that they are not backed by super profitable pharmaceutical companies?

Young Living is a very profitable company. They are big and profitable and will only continue to be more profitable. There is no reason that they could not start testing their own products or set up independent testing.

After your research as a pediatrician, would you use them on your children?

People will read all of this information or even do further research and come to different conclusions from me but here are two reasons I won’t:

1. I do not treat my kids with unnecessary medications. Since they are recommended for symptoms and given with the hopes of reliving those symptoms, I consider these oils to be medication.

2. I believe that, due to the lack of good studies, the use of them in children should be considered experimental at this point.

Summary

• The use of essential oils seems to be growing.
• The evidence for their use in children is slim.
• Talk with your doctor about the products you are using so that they can be aware of potential safety issues and medication interactions. 

Previous articles on this topic:

• New York Times Report: Are Essential Oils Safe For Kids?
• Essential oils and their use on children
• How safe are essential oils for children?

My interest began with a report from the Tennesee poison center that said reports of toxic exposures to oils doubled from 2011 to 2015. Of those reported cases, four out of every five were in children.

As I began my research on essential oils, I asked what you guys wanted to know. I asked on Facebook what you all wanted to know and you guys had some great questions.

Most indicated that they “really wanted to hear my opinion.”

I will take the questions and try to divide them up by category as best as I can.

I feel like I owe it to you, and your children, to give my candid answers on the subject.

Safety

Q: What harm have you seen from patients choosing oils over modern medicine?

A: I’ve seen two examples of this. The first were parents using oils for their child’s eczema. They came to me after one month of attempts (including multiple different regimens) to treat with oils and the child ended up having a secondary staph infection of their eczema because the skin was open. In fairness, severe eczema happens and secondary skin infections happen, but most of my patients with eczema do not get that severe with the medications I typically recommend. The second patient was one who had an upper respiratory infection that led to croup (noisy, barky cough). The parents were trying oils at home for three days (again multiple different attempts to get the “right” oil) before they ended up in the emergency room and admitted for two days for difficulty breathing. The theme here has three components:

1.The oil itself did not hurt the child.

2.The ambiguity as to which oil should be used led to multiple different regimens and oils being tried.

3.The biggest problem with these two is the delay in receiving appropriate care.

Q: What is the best way to explain proper dilution to others?

A: Ummmm…I don’t know. Based on what I have seen regarding research this has not truly been studied, at least in children.

Q: Are there any that are harmful for use topically?

A: There are case reports of severe toxicity with topica application that uses eucalyptus and tea tree oil from those that I studied. These are mainly due to extensive application. Toxicity to any treatment is always related to dose. The more area you cover, the more likely it is to be toxic. There are also some reports of reactions with very small applications. The other concern I have (for which we don’t know the answer yet) is how does the toxicity change when these oils are being applied hourly (as I’ve seen recommended) or when multiple oils are being used at once.

Q: Can I use them in my child with asthma?

There are no studies that show effectiveness for asthma. Any inhaled substance with a small particle size that can get into the lungs could theoretically lead the airways to constrict which would actually cause more problem in children with asthma.

Q: What happens when oil are ingested (purposefully or accidental)?

Even most pro-oil websites don’t recommend ingestion of oils in children and to use extreme caution in adults. Because we do not have studies that evaluate the safety and appropriate dosing for ingestion by children, this is the one hard line I take with my patients who are using them. Please do not use them in this way.

Q: Have you seen allergic reactions?

The allergic reactions I have seen are mostly related to the skin. Application of anything topically can flare a child who has eczema or cause contact irritation of the skin.

Q: Are they really good for you or are you you doing more harm than good?

I don’t think we know the answer to this question on a global scale. If they do have all the anti-bacterial, anti-viral and all other properties, and will actually work for those uses (which are not proven in humans), would we go on to see essential oil-resistant-bacteria? I believe we would. Especially with the way they are currently being used. Basically applying whatever oil for whatever infection (I am basing this on the fact that anytime I see someone requesting help with which oil to use, they routinely get 5-10 suggestions). That is exactly the way resistance to antibiotics occurs - too many antibiotics for non-specific indications and next thing you know a certain antibiotics doesn’t work for certain infection any longer.

Q: Is it safe to use oils along with modern medicines?

We know that these oils can affect the liver and cause the liver to metabolize other medications faster or slower. This could lead to medications not being as effective or potentially be more toxic. Some information is being gathered in adults to try to figure this out but kids are not “little adults” and we’ll likely need research in children before we can answer this for sure.

More from Doc Smitty on this topic:

New York Times Report: Are Essential Oils Safe For Kids?

Essential oils and their use on children

Essential oils and children - more questions answered

But I’ve been asked about some other treatment options. Do they work? Are they safe?

When it comes to “alternative” medications, I try to keep an open mind; but, I basically divide them into three categories:

1. Yep, go for it - Treatment options that have been studied and shown to be safe and effective in kids (or in adults but with reasonable belief it would also be safe and effective in kids).

2.  Meh, if you want, go ahead – Treatment options with mixed studies or no studies proving effectiveness but no studies or reason to believe that they would harm kids.

3. Nope, not a chance – Treatment options that have no studies and no logical pathway by which they could be effective and/or any reason to believe they could be harmful for kids.

Let’s look at a few alternatives:

Elderberry syrup/gummies/soup…

There are some VERY small studies (less than 50 patients) in adults that showed some improvement in flu systems for people already diagnosed with the flu but treated with elderberry within 48 hours of symptom onset.

I cannot find any studies addressing its use in kids or an appropriate dose. Also, despite its frequent use as a preventive option, I can’t find studies that support elderbery will decrease you or your child’s likelihood of getting the flu. I also haven't found a study that says it is safe to give over long periods of time.

So for me, it’s “Meh, if you want, go ahead.” I wouldn’t spend my money on it and I definitely wouldn’t give it over long periods of time for prevention, but I won’t give you a lecture if you are using it over short periods to treat flu-like symptoms.

Oscillococcinum

What is it? It’s a homeopathic medicine (meaning it’s a super diluted substance which supposedly maintains an imprint of the original chemical makeup) made initially from anas barbarae hepatis et cordis extractum 200C, which sounds impressive but is actually Muscovy duck liver. Keep in mind that the mixture is so dilute, it’s actually very unlikely that there is any duck liver present in the little tablets you put in your mouth. But, even if there was, just research how the guy came up with the reason for using duck liver and you’ll understand that there wasn’t much science or even logic that went into the idea in the first place. Large systematic reviews of the studies for use of oscillococcinum for both prevention and treatment of flu have shown no evidence that it works for either.

Fortunately because this is a homeopathic medication (and mostly sugar), there are no major side effects with its use. Because of that, I was tempted to put it into the “Meh” category. But because its use defies all science and logic, I just can’t, so it’s, “Nope, not a chance.”

Essential oils for treatment of symptoms/flu

We’ve covered this one…extensively. Our first post on it is called “Essential Oils and Their Use in Children.” Then you can read, “How safe are essential oils for children?” And finally, “Essential oils and children –more questions answered.” If you don’t have time or interest in reading those, here’s the TL;DR summary: If you use them within reason, and diffuse but don’t ingest, they are a “Meh, if you want, go ahead.”

But, you have to promise me you won’t go crazy and if things aren’t going as expected, or your child is getting worse rather than better, that you will seek help. Do you promise?

Neosporin in the nose to prevent flu

Neosporin is an antibiotic ointment. Flu is viral. There are no studies to support this. I don’t see how this could be helpful. So, “Nope.”

Sinus rinses

Besides the feeling like you got hit by a truck, one of the other most frustrating and annoying problems with the flu is the feeling of congestion so severe that it feels like you can’t breathe. Saline sinus rinses, either as a flush like a Neti-pot or spray and suction for babies, can be helpful to relieve this feeling. So, “Yep, go for it.”

Honey

The cough associated with flu can be deep and severe…but, as you probably know already, I don’t believe that any cough medicines (prescription or over-the-counter) work very well in kids and they can be harmful. So, my go to for cough for kids over one year of age? Honey. Yep, just honey. Yep, just give it with a spoon. Yep, as many times a day as you think your kids needs it. Seriously, just honey. (This might be a conversation I have daily to a parent with a look of complete and utter untrusting disbelief).

There are probably a million other alternative flu treatments out there but these are some of the common one that I get ask about.

What other alternatives have you seen?

James saw Nickolas with a football. He’d waited a long time to throw and catch a football once again with his dad.

It wasn’t that long ago that Nickolas was in tears from the sharp, stabbing feeling in his abdomen. The nerve block procedure he’d just awoken from did little to ease his pain. Groggy from anesthesia, he didn't know what he was saying to Cook Children's pain management physician, Artee Gandhi, M.D. He only knew that the years he'd spent laying on the couch because it hurt too much to move had to end.

"He kept saying 'please help me, you're all I have Dr. Gandhi, you have to help me,'" said Julie McCanless, Nickolas' mother.

The pain in the upper right quadrant of Nickolas' abdomen began suddenly in 2011, when he was just 10 years old. Though he was an active child who enjoyed playing football, there was no injury or incident the family could point to as the trigger for his pain. His parents began searching for someone who could provide a diagnosis and also relief. Despite seeing physicians in Texas, Oklahoma and even Minnesota, no one could tell the North Richland Hills family what was plaguing their son.

"It was out of control. He couldn't play sports anymore. It affected his appetite, his mood, nothing seemed to help," said Julie.

The family tried everything they could think of to ease the pain. Essential oils, massage therapy, acupuncture, they even visited a chiropractor, but none could offer Nickolas reprieve. Out of ideas, they turned to a Dallas pain clinic.

"They put him on every kind of pain medication you could think of from hydrocodone to ibuprofen, Tylenol, all the way to oxycodone and oxycontin," said Julie.

She says the drugs gave him some comfort, but left Nickolas with zero quality of life. He was often too drowsy from the medication to interact with family or friends. Attending school was also made difficult. The McCanless family spent nine months trying to find a prescription that would help without the negative side effects, all while hoping someone would one day give them a diagnosis. Then they turned to the Pain Management program at Cook Children's, one of only 35 pediatric pain clinics in the United States.

Dr. Gandhi helped launch the Pain Management program seven years ago. At the time, she was the only pain management physician at Cook Children’s and would visit patients in their rooms while carrying charts in a roller bag. The program has since grown into a multidisciplinary department complete with two board-certified physicians, clinical, physical and massage therapists, nurses and a biofeedback therapist. Instead of treating pain solely with medication, Dr. Gandhi and her team aim to help patients manage it with relaxation techniques, diet, exercise, lifestyle modifications and sleep.

In Nickolas’ case, Dr. Gandhi used many of these treatments as well as nerve block injections, which interrupt how pain signals are sent to the brain. He’d undergone these injections at other hospitals, and they usually offered temporary relief.

“We decided to try the nerve block injections, but every time it would wear off the pain would return, ” said Dr. Gandhi.

She started to think that Nickolas might have a rare condition known as abdominal cutaneous nerve entrapment syndrome (ACNES). It occurs when a nerve becomes ‘entrapped’ in the abdominal wall. Because it’s not common, ACNES is often overlooked and misdiagnosed for a gastrointestinal issue. Dr. Gandhi knew she would have to think outside of the box in treating Nickolas if she was going to keep her promise to him.

“She said she wasn’t going to give up and she didn’t. No matter how many times the pain blocks failed, she would try to find something else,” said Nickolas.

Dr. Gandhi’s search for a cure led her to believe that surgery might be the answer they were all looking for. She tuned to Chad Hamner, M.D., Trauma Medical Director at Cook Children’s for help.

“I told Dr. Hamner what I thought Nickolas had and that a neurectomy may be helpful,” said Dr. Gandhi.

A neurectomy is performed by removing all or part of a nerve. Dr. Gandhi thought that by removing the nerve she believed was ‘entrapped’ that his pain could be stopped. Dr. Hamner agreed to meet Nickolas to see if surgery was a feasible avenue to explore.

“He did some more investigation as well as an exam and decided to do the surgery, and low and behold, it worked,” said Dr. Gandhi.

Nickolas underwent surgery in April. By mid-May, he was doing things he didn’t think he’d ever do again.

“I asked Nickolas what he’d want to do if the surgery worked. He said ‘throw a football,” said Julie.

Three weeks after surgery, Nickolas bought a football. When his dad arrived home from work that evening, his sister told their father that Nickolas had a surprise for him.

“He put his stuff down and I came running out. I threw him the football and he gave me a big hug. We both started crying,” said Nickolas.

He’s now well on his way to being a normal kid again, running, throwing and hanging out with his friends. His mother says she couldn’t be more thankful.

“I know there are hundreds of children out there going through what my son went through,” Julie said. “The only thing I can tell them is don’t give up.”

To make an appointment with Pain Management, call 682-885-PAIN (7246) phone. Click here to learn more about the program. 

Pain Management at Cook Children's

Cook Children's Pain Management program cares for infants, children and adolescents with chronic and acute pain. C​ook Children's is one of a few children's hospitals in the U.S. providing a comprehensive pediatric pain management program.

The program's goal is to improve the quality of life for our patients by giving them the tools to cope with and overcome pain. Some of the therapy options are medications, interventional pain procedures, medical acupuncture, relaxation therapy, guided imagery, biofeedback, hypnosis and cognitive behavioral therapy. The team also teaches patients and families how to manage pain through exercise, diet, lifestyle modifications, and sleep hygiene.

The team includes two board certified anesthesiologists trained in pain management, a licensed clinical social worker specializing in psychophysiology, a physical therapist, a clinic nurse coordinator, and referral to a dedicated clinical therapist. Click here to learn more.

Some estimate that children will have 8-12 upper respiratory infections (coughs and colds) per year. Because many of those will be clustered in the winter and viral respiratory infections can last 1-2 weeks, it’s possible your child might seem to be sick “all winter long.”

Anytime a child seems to be sick off and on for months at a time, people will search for answers. Anytime people search for answers, they will start to make connections where connections don’t really exist…

So, now it’s time for: Winter Weather Health Myths

Myth No. 1 - Feed a cold and starve a fever.

I don’t care if you decide to feed a cold. If a child is hungry and not vomiting, let them eat but starving a fever doesn’t make sense. Besides, the major thing is that you need to monitor a child’s drinking when they are sick more than their eating. Dehydration is frequently what causes a child with a cold or flu to get sicker and require medical attention. You should encourage (“force”) your child to drink small, frequent sips of whatever fluid they will drink. Pedialyte or Gatorade are good options but milk is fine too (yes, even with fever).

Myth No. 2 – It’s been too cold for my child to exercise.

Maybe, for like two weeks in late January, it’s too cold for your child to exercise OUTSIDE. Otherwise, buy you and your child a sweatshirt and go for a walk. During those two weeks, you can walk circles around the house together or just do some lunges or something. Even 10 minutes a day is better than zero.

Myth No. 3 – Going outside to the cold (wet head or not) will make your child sick.

Cold weather and getting cold doesn’t actually make you sick. Getting sick is the result of being exposed to an infection that makes you sick not by getting cold. We think that viruses tend to increase in activity during winter due to the fact that people are more likely to be crowded inside.

Myth No. 4 – Taking Vitamin C (or a multivitamin or Zinc or essential oils) will protect your child from colds and flu.

The supplement industry has become big business for both adults and children as people look for anything to prevent illness. Unfortunately, study after study show that they simply don’t work. Essential oils are one of the latest to promote the ability to “boost” the immune system but studies are still lacking to show benefit in children. For now, our best bets are simple things like washing hands, covering coughs and getting the flu vaccine (I know it’s not perfect but at least it’s something).

Myth No. 5 – If you don’t like the weather in Texas, wait 5 minutes.

While not technically a myth, because weather can change fast in Texas. Good evidence is the last week. But, we’re not alone. Most of the United States believes that the phrase “If you don’t like the weather in ____, wait 5 minutes” applies to their state. A Google search ranking for this phrase puts Texas at number 8 on the states where this phrase was searched for (behind Massachusetts, New York, Georgia, Pennsylvania, Maine, South Carolina and North Carolina).

Don’t buy into the winter weather myths. Here are some tips for preventing winter weather health issues:

• Help your child eat healthy and get good sleep.
• Get your child up and active in some way every day.
• Teach your child to wash their hand and cover their coughs.
• Get your child a flu shot (it’s still not too late).