Santa Claus stopped by to visit our tiniest patients in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit to spread Christmas cheer. The babies were dressed in festive outfits to celebrate their first Christmas.

Effectiveness/General Use

Do they really work or is it a mind over matter thing?

I think that there are probably some uses for oils that will be studied and proven to work. I think these will be pretty rare and only a small fraction of the claims that are currently made.

So, is it mind of matter (placebo)? Here are some of the most common uses I see for oils in kids:

Teething - It’s not even clear what symptoms teething causes …fussiness, fever, runny nose, etc have all come into question. But, if you give an oil and a symptom goes away, does that mean the oil fixed it? Not likely.

Fever - Fevers come and go during the day with illness, even without medication.

Cough/congestion - The regimens I see where children have oils placed frequently basically make it impossible to know if they do anything for these symptoms. Cough/congestion will be worse at certain times of day and better at others treatment or no.

How close are we to having actual research on the use of oils?

I still think we are quite some time away. Those that are currently doing research are often biased, are not doing high-quality studies and are using small sample sizes.

Marketing

Why are they sold through multi-level marketing (MLM)?

It’s a fast way to get a product out there and make a lot of money. Since I’ve been on social media, I’ve seen several of these types of MLM ideas crop up. The difference with these is I have some specific knowledge about the conditions they are being used for and specific concerns about how their use could harm a population of people that I care very much about. I know very little about bags and good smelling wax that can be melted with a light-bulb so I haven’t gotten involved until now.

In many ways, it protects the big company because they are not the ones out there making claims about the oils and what they can do. That falls to their independent distributors. If someone were to have a bad outcome because of their use of essential oils, who is responsible? If I prescribe a medicine that someone is allergic to, that responsibility falls squarely on my shoulders, not the makers of amoxicillin. If I prescribe the wrong medicine for a kids asthma and something bad happens, that responsibility falls to me.

Are they an increasingly popular trend or just something I was not aware of?

I’m not sure but it certainly does feel like they are gaining in popularity. Social media makes it seem that way at least.

Do you believe the claim that certain brands of oils are superior to others?

I’m sure there are differences but since we don’t even know what they do for the most part, it’s hard to answer this question.

Philosophy/Opinion

Regarding writing about essential oils: Are you mad, man?

Yes, in fact, I think I must be.

What’s the number one reason you see parents using oils instead of medicine?

In general, people are becoming less trusting of experts and organized institutions. Medicine and doctors are no different. The gap between what a doctor knows and what patients know shrinks every day. People can find out information about their conditions and know basically the treatment options that exist. People are looking to live more natural lives and most who use them feel that oils fit within that idea. When you combine these two issues, right or wrong, essential oils seem to step in the gap.

What is a good way to communicate with your doctor about your use of essential oils (for specific conditions and generally)?

I think it’s important to be honest with you doctor about your use of essential oils. As new information is uncovered it would be important for your doctor to be able to show you new research etc, especially if something shows a particular oil to be unsafe. They can only do this if they know about your use of them. Also, as doctors are prescribing medications, we need to know anything you might be on that could cause a drug interaction.

What is your take on the potential political barriers to the study of essential oils given that they are not backed by super profitable pharmaceutical companies?

Young Living is a very profitable company. They are big and profitable and will only continue to be more profitable. There is no reason that they could not start testing their own products or set up independent testing.

After your research as a pediatrician, would you use them on your children?

People will read all of this information or even do further research and come to different conclusions from me but here are two reasons I won’t:

1. I do not treat my kids with unnecessary medications. Since they are recommended for symptoms and given with the hopes of reliving those symptoms, I consider these oils to be medication.

2. I believe that, due to the lack of good studies, the use of them in children should be considered experimental at this point.

Summary

• The use of essential oils seems to be growing.
• The evidence for their use in children is slim.
• Talk with your doctor about the products you are using so that they can be aware of potential safety issues and medication interactions. 

Previous articles on this topic:

• New York Times Report: Are Essential Oils Safe For Kids?
• Essential oils and their use on children
• How safe are essential oils for children?

Last week, a Plano CPS agent responded to a different type of call after a Facebook post inviting parents to bring their children over to be exposed to chickenpox was reported

What is a pox party?

Pox parties were more common prior to the introduction of the chickenpox vaccine in 1995. The general feeling was that, if your child was going to get chickenpox at some point anyway, you might as well get it out of the way. It seemed like a rite of passage that everyone should go through. Because most people survived chickenpox with a few days of itchy annoying rash, there are some that ask me if the vaccine is necessary. “Wouldn’t it be better for us to just get the disease?”

Why do we vaccinate for chickenpox?

Most children with chickenpox develop fever, sore throat and loss of appetite which is followed by the classic rash. I was taught that the rash was like “dew drops on a rose petal” because of the clear, fluid-filled bumps that form on a red base. The rash would then crust over with the crusts lasting one or two weeks before falling off.

It was a memorable disease but not dangerous for most. I happen to remember riding around in the floorboard of my dad’s gas truck (it was a different time for lots of reasons) while I was recuperating, not able to go to school because our local farmer’s couldn’t wait for my rash to heal to have gas for their tractors.

Unfortunately, not all children with chickenpox have a simple course. Here is a list of possible complications that can arise from chickenpox:

1. Skin infections-These could be simple and treated with antibiotics but also can be deeper and involve muscle or other tissues. This would be more dangerous now that we see more antibiotic resistant bacteria.

2. Neurologic complications-Infection of the tissue around the brain could lead to confusion and infection of a particular part of the brain lead to a loss of coordination, both complications lead to hospitalization.

3. Less frequent complications-Pneumonia and hepatitis (liver infection) can also occur but do so less commonly.

Prior to the vaccination, there were 11,000 hospitalizations and 100 deaths from varicella yearly. About three children out of 1000 infected required hospitalization. Since 1996, hospitalizations and deaths have fallen significantly (70 and 88 percent).

Is there anything wrong with having a pox party?

As best as I can tell (I am not a lawyer), there is nothing illegal about throwing a pox party. One thing is clear, sending lollipops through the mail (even pox parties want to be the next Uber) to infect others is. There is also a picture that has been shared around the internet which reportedly quotes the mom from the Plano area pox party as saying, “I had to open my husband’s shingles blister and swab their mouths.” I have a feeling most of those out there who would throw or go to a pox party would consider this a little much.

Should CPS have been called?

I have to say when I first read this story; I thought that the call to CPS was a little overboard. CPS is busy as it is. Investigating pox parties is probably not the best use of their time. I have served on local CPS boards and the things that we talked about needed the full attention of a staff that was already stretched thin.

Secondly, the likelihood of serious harm resulting from contracting chickenpox is overall pretty low. Should CPS be called for every parenting infraction that minutely increases the risk of harm to children? No. That would mean I should report every family that turns their child’s car seat around at 21 months or that allows their baby to sleep on their stomachs. While I disagree with those decisions, I choose to educate as best as I can but don’t log on and report them to CPS.

My only pause in this case came from what I admit is a slippery slope argument but stick with me for just a second. What if one of these children ended up seriously harmed as a result of contracting chickenpox at this party?

Seeing children suffer from vaccine preventable diseases (pertussis is the most common which admittedly occurs in both vaccinated and unvaccinated babies) is hard. If I saw a child suffering from a complication of chickenpox only to discover that the child had contracted chickenpox intentionally at a pox party, this would be even harder.

How can we prevent against chickenpox?

The most effective and best way is through vaccination. Vaccination at age 1 and 4 years protects against 90 percent of chickenpox disease and 99 percent against severe disease. Rarely, children can get chickenpox after they have been vaccinated but the cases seem to be milder.